- Fr. Haralambos (Bob) Fox — August 1, 2015 – Present
- Fr. Simon Thomas — August 16, 2006 – July 5, 2015
- Fr. Paul Paris (2002 – 2006)
- Fr. James Adams (2002)
- Fr. Constantine Zozos (1980 – 2002)
- Fr. Leon Pachis (1980)
- Fr. Nicholas Manousakis (1975 – 1979)
- Fr. George Tsompanas (1973 – 1975)
- Fr. George Hadjis (1972 – 1973)
- Fr. Stephanos Vlahopoulos (1971 – 1972)
- Fr. Peter Ballan (1970 – 1971)
- Fr. Constantine Palassis (1968 – 1970)
- Fr. Demetrios Leon (1966 – 1968)
- Fr. Lambros Vakalakis (1963 – 1966)
- Fr. Peter Rellos (1962 – 1963)
- Fr. Anthony Sipsas (1957 – 1962)
- Fr. Constantine Palassis (1955 – 1957)
- Fr. Constantine Mitsopoulos (1952 – 1955)
- Fr. Ambrosios Mandelaris (1946 – 1951)
- Fr. Constantine Genis (1943 – 1945)